Mortgage Applications Fall 2.3% as MBA's 30-Year Rate Climbs to 7.35%. What Borrowers Should Compare Now

MBA says applications fell 2.3% in the week ended Nov. 13 as its 30-year contract rate rose to 7.35%. Here is how that survey differs from Freddie Mac's and what borrowers should compare.

By Anthony Brikho · 5 min read

A newly built blue two-story house with a For Sale sign in New Orleans.

Mortgage demand cooled last week as rates moved back up. Total mortgage applications fell 2.3% on a seasonally adjusted basis in the week ended Nov. 13, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association's Weekly Mortgage Applications Survey released Nov. 18. The decline followed a 6.2% jump the week before, when easing rates had briefly drawn borrowers back.

The average contract rate on a 30-year fixed loan with a conforming balance rose to 7.35% from 7.21%, the highest level in three weeks. For borrowers, the more useful question is not whether a single weekly number went up, but what the move says about the quotes they are likely to see and how to compare them.

What the survey showed

MBA's figures for the week ended Nov. 13:

  • Total applications: down 2.3% from the prior week, seasonally adjusted, and down 5% unadjusted.
  • Purchase applications: down 3% seasonally adjusted; the unadjusted purchase index was 18% lower than the same week a year earlier.
  • Refinance applications: down 2% from the prior week and 54% lower than a year earlier. Even so, the refinance share of all applications rose to 41.1% from 39.8%, because purchase activity fell faster.
  • FHA: FHA refinances rose almost 7%, and the FHA share of total applications increased to 16.1% from 15.5%.
  • Adjustable-rate loans: the ARM share of applications slipped to 10.8%.
  • Rates and points: the 30-year conforming contract rate rose to 7.35% from 7.21%, and points, including the origination fee, rose to 0.79 from 0.75 for loans with a 20% down payment.

"Treasury yields rose last week amid data showing inflation accelerated in October and Fed officials acknowledging that additional rate hikes may be needed in the coming months," said Joel Kan, MBA's vice president and deputy chief economist, in the release. He said renewed affordability challenges from elevated rates "have pushed prospective homebuyers to the sidelines," and noted that the FHA rate was around 30 basis points below the conforming rate, which supported refinancing for some homeowners.

Why this is not a measure of home sales

The MBA survey counts mortgage applications, not closed loans or completed home purchases. An application can be withdrawn, denied or never close, and a single buyer may apply with more than one lender. Weekly numbers also swing with holidays and seasonal patterns, which is why MBA reports both seasonally adjusted and unadjusted figures. One week's decline is a signal about borrower activity, not proof that the housing market has turned.

The year-over-year comparisons are often more informative than the weekly change. Purchase activity 18% below a year earlier and refinancing more than half below a year earlier point to a market where higher rates continue to limit demand.

Two rate surveys, two methods

Borrowers sometimes see different "average mortgage rates" in the same week and wonder which is right. They measure different things.

MBA's 7.35% figure is an average contract rate on 30-year fixed loans with conforming balances, which MBA identifies as loans at or below the $832,750 limit, for borrowers with a 20% down payment. MBA reports the points paid alongside it. The weekly survey covers the week the applications were taken.

Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey is a separate measure, based on applications lenders submit to Freddie Mac, and is published on Thursdays. Its Nov. 12 reading put the average 30-year fixed rate at 7.11%, down from 7.18% the prior week. The two surveys use different samples and timing, so their numbers should not be expected to match. The next Freddie Mac reading will show whether its average also moved higher.

Neither figure is a quote. The rate an individual borrower is offered depends on credit score, down payment, loan size and type, property, points paid and the length of the rate lock.

What borrowers can do now

  • Compare rate and points together. The rise in average points from 0.75 to 0.79 is a reminder that a lower advertised rate can come with higher upfront costs. Ask each lender for the same loan scenario with and without points.
  • Get same-day Loan Estimates. Rates change daily. Request official Loan Estimates from several lenders on the same day for the same loan amount, loan type and lock period. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's Loan Estimate guide shows where to find the rate, points, lender fees and estimated cash to close.
  • Consider whether an FHA loan fits. MBA said FHA rates were about 30 basis points below conforming rates last week. FHA loans carry their own mortgage insurance costs, so compare the total monthly payment and upfront costs, not just the rate.
  • Look at the lock period. If you are under contract, a rate lock long enough to reach closing can protect you from further increases. Ask what an extension would cost if the closing slips.
  • Weigh refinancing carefully. If your current rate is already below today's averages, a refinance makes sense mainly for specific goals, such as removing mortgage insurance. Calculate how long it would take to recover the closing costs.

The bottom line

Last week's pullback in applications followed a rise in rates tied to inflation data and Fed commentary, according to MBA. It is one week of data in a volatile market. For borrowers, the practical response is the same in any week: compare full offers in writing, pay attention to points as well as rate, and choose a lock that matches the closing timeline.

A newly built house for sale on Prieur Street in the Broadmoor neighborhood of New Orleans, September 2023. This archival photo illustrates the housing market; it does not depict a property connected to the survey. Photo: Infrogmation / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Used at the 1280 × 845 Commons rendition, uncropped (social previews may show a center crop).

Related coverage

Explore more coverage

Browse the full mortgage.news archive