Housing Starts Rebound in October, but Permits Point to a Weaker Pipeline
Starts rose to a 1.309 million annual pace, while single-family permits fell 8.7%. Wide survey margins mean the reported increase in starts is not statistically conclusive.
By Christopher Salem · 4 min read
U.S. home construction picked up in October after a weak September, but a fall in building permits gave a less encouraging view of the construction pipeline. The Census Bureau and the Department of Housing and Urban Development reported Wednesday, Nov. 18, that housing starts reached a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 1.309 million, up 9.9% from September’s revised 1.191 million pace.
The increase comes with an important qualification. Its 90% confidence interval was plus or minus 16.8 percentage points, wide enough to include a decline. The agencies said there was insufficient statistical evidence to conclude that the actual change differed from zero. October’s preliminary estimate is not, by itself, proof of a construction recovery.
Starts improved, while permits fell
Single-family starts rose an estimated 4.0% to an annual pace of 864,000. That monthly change also fell within a confidence interval that included zero. Starts in buildings with at least five units reached a 433,000 annual pace, compared with 345,000 in September. An annualized rate describes what a month’s seasonally adjusted pace would look like over a year. It is not the number of homes started during October.
Permits moved the other way. Total authorizations fell 7.4% to a 1.295 million annual rate. Single-family permits dropped 8.7% to 772,000. Those figures matter because permits track homes authorized for construction, rather than work already begun. A permit is not a guarantee that a home will be built, but fewer authorizations can signal a thinner supply of future projects.
Completed homes are a different measure
Housing completions reached a 1.272 million annual pace, up an estimated 6.5% from September. That increase was also not statistically conclusive. Single-family completions stood at a 900,000 annual rate. Starts, permits and completions describe different stages: authorized projects, construction getting underway and homes being finished.
For buyers, that distinction keeps a national headline in perspective. A rise in starts does not put finished homes on the market immediately, and the national total includes apartments as well as houses. The mix of properties and stage of construction near a buyer’s preferred neighborhood may look very different.
What borrowers should watch locally
For a buyer considering new construction, the practical questions remain specific to the property: whether it is permitted, how far construction has progressed, what completion date the builder is committing to and how that timing fits the financing. A national annualized estimate cannot establish when a particular home will be ready or what mortgage rate a lender will offer.
The agencies also caution that several months of data may be needed to establish an underlying trend. October’s starts estimate improved, but the permits decline and wide survey margins argue against treating one release as an all-clear for housing supply.
The U.S. Census Bureau’s headquarters in Suitland, Maryland, in March 2007. Archival photograph: U.S. Census Bureau, public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. Used at the 1280 × 706 Commons rendition of the 3264 × 1800 original, uncropped (social previews may show a center crop).